Little Cayman Beach Resort vs. Cayman Brac Beach Resort: Which Is Right for You?
- The Scuba Holiday Blog Team
- Jul 2
- 5 min read
A Tale of Two Islands
If you're dreaming of a Caribbean dive getaway but can't decide between Little Cayman Beach Resort and Cayman Brac Beach Resort, you're not alone. Both are sister properties under the Clearly Cayman umbrella, and both offer world-class diving, full-service accommodations, and easygoing island charm. But depending on your travel style, one may suit you just a little more than the other.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Feature | Little Cayman Beach Resort | Cayman Brac Beach Resort |
Island Vibe | Quiet, remote, serene | Friendly, relaxed, more developed |
Ideal For | Couples, photographers, smaller groups | Couples, Dive clubs, families, mixed groups |
Top Dive Sites | Bloody Bay Wall, Jackson's Reef | Captain Keith Tibbetts, Wilderness Wall |
Bonus Dive Access | Direct access to Bloody Bay Wall | Morning trip to Bloody Bay (weather permitting) |
Nightlife | Minimal (bring a good book) | Casual bar scene, social vibes |
Nearby Attractions | Nature trails, beaches, lagoon wildlife. Booby pond | Caves, bluff hikes, island tours |
Accessibility | Requires inter-island flight. Twin otter only | Easier access via Cayman Brac airport |
Diving Experience
Both resorts offer first class valet style diving with large spacious Pro 42' boats and an amazing crew who's focus is on your safety and enjoyment.
Little Cayman offers Bloody Bay wall and many incredible dive sites like Jackson's Bight and Mixing bowl. You are guaranteed to see turtles rays and those super friendly groupers. If you are really lucky and the time of year is right you could see a yellow headed jaw fish with it's babies in it's mouth
Cayman Brac offers amazing dives, such as the MV Captain Keith Tibbetts, which is an incredibly cool shipwreck, and Wilderness Wall, where you'll find turtles, angelfish, eagle rays, and large barrel sponges.
Little Cayman Beach Resort
This resort is steps away from the legendary Bloody Bay Marine Park, home to some of the Caribbean’s most celebrated wall diving. Calm conditions, rich marine life, and incredible visibility make it ideal for underwater photography and long bottom times.
Dive packages include:
6 days of 2-tank morning boat dives (12 total)
5 single-tank afternoon dives
Complimentary dive computer use
Easy boat access to premier dive sites daily
Cayman Brac Beach Resort
Cayman Brac offers more variety, with a mix of wall dives, swim-throughs, and wrecks—including the iconic Captain Keith Tibbetts, a 330-foot Russian frigate. As a bonus, guests enjoy a weather-permitting morning dive trip to Bloody Bay Wall on nearby Little Cayman.
Dive packages mirror those of Little Cayman:
6 days of 2-tank AM dives + 5 single-tank PM dives
Dive computer included
Access to both Brac and Little Cayman dive sites
Accommodations & Resort Atmosphere
Both resorts feature charming rooms with island-inspired decor, air conditioning, and pool or garden views. While neither is ultra-modern, both are clean, comfortable, and well-maintained with excellent hospitality.
At Little Cayman Beach Resort, the accommodations are built for peace and simplicity, aligning with the resort’s tranquil, remote vibe. The rooms are cozy and functional, designed for divers who appreciate quiet evenings and restful nights. Many guests appreciate the intimate layout and minimal foot traffic around the property, which adds to the relaxed feel of the resort. It’s a favorite for couples and solo travelers looking for serenity between dives.
In contrast, Cayman Brac Beach Resort has a slightly more spacious feel and a more social layout. The resort is spread across a wider footprint, offering more communal areas where guests can mingle after dives. The on-site bar often hosts casual gatherings and live music, creating a more dynamic, lively atmosphere without sacrificing the laid-back charm of island life. It’s particularly popular with dive groups and repeat guests who enjoy a balance of great diving and sociability.
Food, Amenities & Extras
Both properties offer full meal plans with hearty breakfasts, hot lunches, and freshly prepared dinners. Meals are served buffet-style in a relaxed, communal setting, perfect for fueling up between dives or winding down in the evening. The menus include a mix of Caribbean flavors and international staples, with vegetarian options and themed dinners throughout the week. Guests often rave about the fresh ingredients, flavorful dishes, and laid-back, social dining atmosphere.
At Little Cayman Beach Resort, the vibe is more subdued—ideal for those who prefer quiet meals, ocean views, and early evenings after a day of wall diving. Meanwhile, Cayman Brac Beach Resort adds a bit more energy to its dining experience with occasional live music and events that bring the dive community together.
Beyond dining, both resorts feature amenities like oceanfront pools, shaded hammocks, and gear rinse stations. On-site bars serve tropical cocktails, and staff are known for their warm hospitality. Whether you want to nap in a hammock or chat with fellow divers over a cold drink, both resorts deliver classic Caribbean comfort with a diver-first focus.
Accessibility & Travel Tips
Little Cayman: Requires a short inter-island flight from Grand Cayman. Worth it for the seclusion and access to world-famous dive walls.
Cayman Brac: More direct access with more flights and larger plane access. Great for those looking to minimize travel complexity.
All travel must begin on a Saturday and includes a 7-night stay.
Which One’s for You?
Choose Little Cayman Beach Resort if you want:
Legendary wall dives and a focus on underwater photography
A quiet, unplugged retreat
Fewer distractions and total reef immersion
Choose Cayman Brac Beach Resort if you want:
A more social and accessible experience
Wreck dives plus Bloody Bay (weather permitting)
Easy travel and additional topside activities
📸 Share Your Dive Story With Us!
Have you stayed at Little Cayman Beach Resort or Cayman Brac Beach Resort? Whether you're a past guest or just discovering us, we'd love to see your adventures! 🌊
Tag us in your dive photos, reef videos, or beachside memories from either resort — or send them directly to our team. Your story might be featured on our blog, social media, or future travel guides to inspire other divers!
📧 Email us at travel@scubaholidays.com or tag us on Instagram and Facebook using #ScubaHolidays
Let’s celebrate the amazing underwater world and the people who explore it together.
Dive Packages with Scuba Holidays
We’ve bundled everything for a seamless escape. Here's what’s included at both resorts:
Little Cayman Beach Resort Package:
Airport ground transfers
Welcome rum punch & cocktail reception
7 nights’ accommodation
Breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily
17 boat dives (6 x 2-tank AM + 5 x 1-tank PM)
Complimentary dive computer use
Complimentary Wi-Fi
All resort fees, taxes & gratuities (excluding dive gratuities)
Cayman Brac Beach Resort Package:
• Airport ground transfers
• Welcome rum punch
• Manager’s cocktail reception
• 7 nights’ accommodation
• Breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily
• 17 boat dives: 6 X 2-tank AM + 5 x 1-tank PM boat dives
• Morning dive trip to Little Cayman to dive Bloody Bay Marine Park included (weather permitting)
• Complimentary use of dive computer
• Complimentary WiFi
• Resort fees, taxes, & gratuities – except dive gratuities which are NOT included
***All travel requires Saturday arrivals with 7-night stays.**
Comments